Comet dust as a mixture of aggregates and solid particles: model consistent with ground-based and space-mission results

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new comet dust model combining aggregates and solid particles, aligning with ground-based and space mission data, and improves quantitative fits to observational polarization and spectral properties.

Contribution

The model integrates aggregates and compact particles based on spacecraft findings, providing a better quantitative match to observational data than previous models.

Findings

Good fit to polarization curves

Reproduces dust color and albedo

Matches in situ particle ratios

Abstract

The most successful model of comet dust presents comet particles as aggregates of submicron grains. It qualitatively explains the spectral and angular change in the comet brightness and polarization and is consistent with the thermal infrared data and composition of the comet dust obtained {\it in situ} for comet 1P/Halley. However, it experiences some difficulties in providing a quantitative fit to the observational data. Here we present a model that considers comet dust as a mixture of aggregates and compact particles. The model is based on the Giotto and Stardust mission findings that both aggregates (made mainly of organics, silicates, and carbon) and solid silicate particles are present in the comet dust. We simulate aggregates as {\bf Ballistic Cluster-Cluster Aggregates (BCCA)} and compact particles as polydisperse spheroids with some distribution of the aspect ratio. The particles follow a power-law size distribution with the power -3 that is close to the one obtained for comet dust {\it in situ}, at studies of the Stardust returned samples, and the results of ground-based observations of comets. The model provides a good fit to the angular polarization curve. It also reproduces the positive spectral gradient of polarization, red color of the dust, and {\bf low albedo. It also has the ratio of compact to fluffy particles close to the one found {\it in situ} for comet 1P/Halley} and the mass ratio of silicate to carbonaceous materials equal to unity that is in accordance with the elemental abundances of Halley's dust found by Giotto mission.