Temporal comparison of nonthermal flare emission and magnetic-flux change rates

TL;DR

This study investigates the temporal relationship between magnetic flux change rates and nonthermal flare emissions across different flare intensities, confirming the standard flare model and linking reconnection flux to CME speed.

Contribution

It provides a detailed comparison of magnetic flux change rates with nonthermal emissions in multiple flare events, highlighting correlations and flux quantities across different GOES classes.

Findings

Strong correlation between magnetic-flux change rate and nonthermal emission.

Reconnection flux increases with flare energy and CME speed.

Reconnection flux ratios are close to unity across events.

Abstract

To test the standard flare model (CSHKP-model), we measured the magnetic-flux change rate in five flare events of different GOES classes using chromospheric/photospheric observations and compared its progression with observed nonthermal flare emission. We calculated the cumulated positive and negative magnetic flux participating in the reconnection process, as well as the total reconnection flux. Finally, we investigated the relations between the total reconnection flux, the GOES class of the events, and the linear velocity of the flare-associated CMEs. Using high-cadence H-alpha and TRACE 1600 A image time-series data and MDI/SOHO magnetograms, we measured the required observables (newly brightened flare area and magnetic-field strength inside this area). RHESSI and INTEGRAL hard X-ray time profiles in nonthermal energy bands were used as observable proxies for the flare-energy release rate. We detected strong temporal correlations between the derived magnetic-flux change rate and the observed nonthermal emission of all events. The cumulated positive and negative fluxes, with flux ratios of between 0.64 and 1.35, were almost equivalent to each other. Total reconnection fluxes ranged between 1.8 x 10^21 Mx for the weakest event (GOES class B9.5) and 15.5 x 10^21 Mx for the most energetic one (GOES class X17.2). The amount of magnetic flux participating in the reconnection process was higher in more energetic events than in weaker ones. Flares with more reconnection flux were associated with faster CMEs.