Higher-order multipole amplitudes in charmonium radiative transitions

TL;DR

This study measures higher multipole amplitudes in charmonium radiative transitions, confirming theoretical predictions and resolving discrepancies with previous measurements using a large data sample.

Contribution

First precise measurement of M2 amplitudes in charmonium radiative transitions using unbinned maximum likelihood fits on extensive data.

Findings

Good agreement with theoretical M2 amplitude predictions.

Determined ratios of normalized M2 amplitudes with uncertainties.

Contrasts with some previous experimental results.

Abstract

Using 24 million $\psi' \equiv \psi(2S)$ decays in CLEO-c, we have searched for higher multipole admixtures in electric-dipole-dominated radiative transitions in charmonia. We find good agreement between our data and theoretical predictions for magnetic quadrupole (M2) amplitudes in the transitions $\psi' \to \gamma \chi_{c1,2}$ and $\chi_{c1,2} \to \gamma J/\psi$, in striking contrast to some previous measurements. Let $b_2^J$ and $a_2^J$ denote the normalized M2 amplitudes in the respective aforementioned decays, where the superscript $J$ refers to the angular momentum of the $\chi_{cJ}$. By performing unbinned maximum likelihood fits to full five-parameter angular distributions, we determine the ratios $a_2^{J=1}/a_2^{J=2} = 0.67^{+0.19}_{-0.13}$ and $a_2^{J=1}/b_2^{J=1} = -2.27^{+0.57}_{-0.99}$, where the theoretical predictions are independent of the charmed quark magnetic moment and are $a_2^{J=1}/a_2^{J=2} = 0.676 \pm 0.071$ and $a_2^{J=1}/b_2^{J=1} = -2.27 \pm 0.16$.