The red halos of SDSS low surface brightness disk galaxies

TL;DR

This study investigates the extremely red stellar halos of low surface brightness disk galaxies using stacked SDSS images, revealing a consistent red excess incompatible with normal stellar populations and exploring potential explanations.

Contribution

It provides the first detailed statistical analysis of faint galaxy halos showing a persistent red excess, and discusses possible physical origins for this anomaly.

Findings

Red halo colours are incompatible with normal stellar populations.

The red excess is not due to sky subtraction residuals.

Dust extinction and bottom-heavy stellar populations are plausible explanations.

Abstract

The faint stellar halos of galaxies contain key information about the oldest stars and the process of galaxy formation. A previous study of stacked SDSS images of disk galaxies has revealed a halo with an abnormally red r-i colour, seemingly inconsistent with our current understanding of stellar halos. Here, we investigate the statistical properties of the faint envelopes of low surface brightness disk galaxies to look for further support for a red excess. 1510 edge-on low surface brightness galaxies were selected from the SDSS Data Release 5, rescaled to the same apparent size, aligned and stacked. This procedure allows us to reach a surface brightness of mu_g ~ 31 mag arcsec^-2. After a careful assessment of instrumental light scattering effects, we derive median and average radial surface brightness and colour profiles in g,r and i. The sample is then divided into 3 subsamples according to g-r colour. All three samples exhibit a red colour excess in r-i in the thick disk/halo region. The halo colours of the full sample, g-r = 0.60+-0.15 and r-i = 0.80+-0.15, are found to be incompatible with the colours of any normal type of stellar population. The fact that no similar colour anomaly is seen at comparable surface brightness levels along the disk rules out a sky subtraction residual as the source of the extreme colours. A number of possible explanations for these abnormally red halos are discussed. We find that two different scenarios -- dust extinction of extragalactic background light and a stellar population with a very bottom-heavy initial mass function -- appear to be broadly consistent with our observations and with similar red excesses reported in the halos of other types of galaxies.