On the distribution of frequency ratios of kHz QPOs

TL;DR

This paper investigates how detection biases influence the observed distribution of kHz QPO frequency ratios in neutron stars, showing that apparent clustering around 3/2 is likely due to observational effects rather than intrinsic resonance.

Contribution

The study demonstrates that detection sensitivity and data analysis methods can create artificial peaks in QPO frequency ratio distributions, challenging previous resonance-based interpretations.

Findings

Detection biases cause apparent clustering around 3/2 in frequency ratios.

Simultaneous detection of both QPOs is limited to specific frequency ranges.

Observed ratio clustering does not necessarily indicate intrinsic resonance.

Abstract

The width (W), root mean squared amplitude (Rs) of lower and upper kHz quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) from accreting neutron stars vary with frequency. Similarly, the QPO frequency varies with the source count rate (S). Hence, the significance of a QPO, scaling as S x Rs^2/W^(1/2) will also depend on frequency. In addition, the significance also scales up with the square root of the integration time of the Fourier power density spectrum (T). Consequently, depending on the way data are considered, kHz QPOs may be detected only over a limited range of their frequency spans or detected predominantly at some frequencies, leading potentially to biases in the observed distributions of frequencies or frequency ratios. Although subject of much controversy, an observed clustering of QPO frequency ratios around 3/2 in Sco X-1, also seen in other sources, has been previously used as an argument supporting resonance based models of neutron star QPOs. In this paper, we measure how the statistical significance of both kHz QPOs vary with frequency for three prototype neutron star kHz QPO sources, namely 4U1636-536, 4U0614+091 and Sco X-1. As the significance of QPO detection depends on frequency, we show that in sensitivity-limited observations (as in the case of the RXTE/PCA), a simultaneous detection of both the lower and upper kHz QPOs can only be achieved over limited frequency ranges. As a result, even a uniform distribution of QPO frequencies will lead to peaks (in particular around 3/2) in the histogram of frequency ratios. This implies that the observed clustering of ratios does not provide any evidence for intrinsically preferred frequency ratios, thus weakening the case for a resonance mechanism at the origin of neutron star kHz QPOs.