Constraints on the multi-TeV particle population in the Coma Galaxy Cluster with H.E.S.S. observations

TL;DR

This study used H.E.S.S. telescopes to search for TeV gamma-ray emission from the Coma Cluster, setting upper limits that challenge existing models of cosmic-ray populations and gamma-ray production in galaxy clusters.

Contribution

First to provide stringent TeV gamma-ray upper limits for the Coma Cluster, constraining cosmic-ray proton energy content and testing theoretical emission models.

Findings

No gamma-ray emission detected above 1 TeV.

Upper limits constrain cosmic-ray energy to about 0.2 times the thermal energy.

Most optimistic models of gamma-ray emission are ruled out.

Abstract

The H.E.S.S. (High Energy Stereoscopic System) telescopes observed Coma for ~8hr in a search for gamma-ray emission at energies >1TeV. The large 3.5deg FWHM field of view of H.E.S.S. is ideal for viewing a range of targets at various sizes including the Coma cluster core, the radio-relic (1253+275) and merger/infall (NGC 4839) regions to the southwest, and features greater than deg away. No evidence for point-like nor extended TeV gamma-ray emission was found and upper limits to the TeV flux F(E) for E>1, >5, and >10TeV were set for the Coma core and other regions. Converting these limits to an energy flux E^2F(E) the lowest or most constraining is the E>5TeV upper limit for the Coma core (0.2deg radius) at ~8Crab flux units or ~10^{-13}ph cm^{-2} s^{-1}. The upper limits for the Coma core were compared with a prediction for the gamma-ray emission from proton--proton interactions, the level of which ultimately scales with the mass of the Coma cluster. A direct constraint using our most stringent limit for E>5 TeV, on the total energy content in non-thermal protons with injection energy spectrum proportional to E^{-2.1} and spatial distribution following the thermal gas in the cluster, is found to be ~0.2 times the thermal energy, or ~10^{62}erg. The E>5 TeV gamma-ray threshold in this case corresponds to cosmic-ray proton energies >50TeV. Our upper limits rule out the most optimistic theoretical models for gamma ray emission from clusters and complement radio observations which constrain the cosmic ray content in clusters at significantly lower proton energies, subject to assumptions on the magnetic field strength.