Gamma-rays from dark matter annihilations strongly constrain the substructure in halos

TL;DR

This paper uses gamma-ray observations to constrain dark matter substructure in halos, showing that certain models imply detectable gamma-ray signals and setting limits on the minimum subhalo mass, with implications for dark matter theories.

Contribution

It provides new constraints on dark matter substructure mass scale using gamma-ray data and simulations, challenging cold dark matter expectations.

Findings

Gamma-ray observations limit the minimum substructure mass to > 5x10^-3 M_sun.

Future Fermi data could raise this limit to > 10^3 M_sun.

Simulations show gamma-ray emission from cosmic rays mimics dark matter signals.

Abstract

Recently, it has been shown that electrons and positrons from dark matter (DM) annihilations provide an excellent fit to the Fermi, PAMELA, and HESS data. Using this DM model, which requires an enhancement of the annihilation cross section over its standard value to match the observations, we show that it immediately implies an observable level of gamma-ray emission for the Fermi telescope from nearby galaxy clusters such as Virgo and Fornax. We show that this DM model implies a peculiar feature from final state radiation that is a distinctive signature of DM. Using the EGRET upper limit on the gamma-ray emission from Virgo, we constrain the minimum mass of substructures within DM halos to be > 5x10^-3 M_sun -- about four orders of magnitudes larger than the expectation for cold dark matter. This limits the cutoff scale in the linear matter power spectrum to k < 35/kpc which can be explained by e.g., warm dark matter. Very near future Fermi observations will strongly constrain the minimum mass to be > 10^3 M_sun: if the true substructure cutoff is much smaller than this, the DM interpretation of the Fermi/PAMELA/HESS data must be wrong. To address the problem of astrophysical foregrounds, we performed high-resolution, cosmological simulations of galaxy clusters that include realistic cosmic ray (CR) physics. We compute the dominating gamma-ray emission signal resulting from hadronic CR interactions and find that it follows a universal spectrum and spatial distribution. If we neglect the anomalous enhancement factor and assume standard values for the cross section and minimum subhalo mass, the same model of DM predicts comparable levels of the gamma-ray emission from DM annihilations and CR interactions. This suggests that spectral subtraction techniques could be applied to detect the annihilation signal.