Possible Resonances in the 12C + 12C Fusion Rate and Superburst Ignition

TL;DR

This paper investigates the superburst ignition mechanism in neutron stars, confirming 12C + 12C fusion as the trigger and proposing a potential resonance near 1.5 MeV that could reconcile models with observations.

Contribution

It demonstrates that electron captures are not triggers and suggests a resonance in 12C + 12C fusion could explain observed ignition depths.

Findings

Electron captures are thermally stable and not triggers.

A hypothetical resonance near 1.5 MeV could reduce ignition depth predictions.

Resonance measurements are feasible with upcoming facilities.

Abstract

Observationally inferred superburst ignition depths are shallower than models predict. We address this discrepancy by reexamining the superburst trigger mechanism. We first explore the hypothesis of Kuulkers et al. that exothermic electron captures trigger superbursts. We find that all electron capture reactions are thermally stable in accreting neutron star oceans and thus are not a viable trigger mechanism. Fusion reactions other than 12C + 12C are infeasible as well since the possible reactants either deplete at much shallower depths or have prohibitively large Coulomb barriers. Thus we confirm the proposal of Cumming & Bildsten and Strohmayer & Brown that 12C + 12C triggers superbursts. We then examine the 12C + 12C fusion rate. The reaction cross-section is experimentally unknown at astrophysically relevant energies, but resonances exist in the 12C + 12C system throughout the entire measured energy range. Thus it is likely, and in fact has been predicted, that a resonance exists near the Gamow peak energy ~ 1.5 MeV. For such a hypothetical 1.5 MeV resonance, we derive both a fiducial value and upper limit to the resonance strength and find that such a resonance could decrease the theoretically predicted superburst ignition depth by up to a factor of 4; in this case, observationally inferred superburst ignition depths would accord with model predictions for a range of plausible neutron star parameters. Said differently, such a resonance would decrease the temperature required for unstable 12C ignition at a column depth 10^12 g/cm^2 from 6 x 10^8 K to 5 x 10^8 K. Determining the existence of a strong resonance in the Gamow window requires measurements of the 12C + 12C cross-section down to a center-of-mass energy near 1.5 MeV, which is within reach of the proposed DUSEL facility.