The origin of redshift asymmetries: How LambdaCDM explains anomalous redshift

TL;DR

This study explains observed redshift asymmetries in galaxy groups within the LambdaCDM model, attributing them to unbound groups and misidentification of the brightest galaxy, without invoking new physics.

Contribution

It demonstrates that redshift excesses can be explained by group dynamics and identification issues within standard cosmological simulations, negating the need for anomalous redshift mechanisms.

Findings

Redshift excess occurs in unbound, misidentified groups.

Bound groups do not show significant redshift asymmetry.

Magnitude-limited observations influence redshift measurements.

Abstract

Several authors have found a statistically significant excess of galaxies with higher redshifts relative to the group centre, so-called discordant redshifts, in particular in groups where the brightest galaxy, identified in apparent magnitudes, is a spiral. Our aim is to explain the observed redshift excess. We use a semi-analytical galaxy catalogue constructed from the Millennium Simulation to study redshift asymmetries in spiral-dominated groups in the Lambda cold dark matter (LambdaCDM) cosmology. We show that discordant redshifts in small galaxy groups arise when these groups are gravitationally unbound and the dominant galaxy of the group is misidentified. The redshift excess is especially significant when the apparently brightest galaxy can be identified as a spiral, in full agreement with observations. On the other hand, the groups that are gravitationally bound do not show a significant redshift asymmetry. When the dominant members of groups in mock catalogues are identified by using the absolute B-band magnitudes, our results show a small blueshift excess. This result is due to the magnitude limited observations that miss the faint background galaxies in groups. When the group centre is not correctly identified it may cause the major part of the observed redshift excess. If the group is also gravitationally unbound, the level of the redshift excess becomes as high as in observations. There is no need to introduce any "anomalous" redshift mechanism to explain the observed redshift excess. Further, as the Friends-of-Friends percolation algorithm picks out the expanding parts of groups, in addition to the gravitationally bound group cores, group catalogues constructed in this way cannot be used as if the groups are purely bound systems.