Simultaneous polarization monitoring of supernovae SN2008D/XT080109 and SN2007uy: isolating geometry from dust

TL;DR

This study uses polarization measurements of supernovae SN2008D and SN2007uy to infer their geometries and the role of dust, revealing potential differences in their intrinsic shapes and orientations.

Contribution

It provides the first simultaneous polarization analysis of two nearby supernovae, isolating geometric effects from dust contributions and suggesting differing intrinsic geometries.

Findings

SN2008D shows variable polarization indicating aspherical expansion.

SN2007uy exhibits constant polarization consistent with interstellar effects.

The supernovae likely have different intrinsic geometries.

Abstract

The possible existence of a continuum encompassing the diversity of explosive stellar deaths,ranging from ordinary SNe to relativistic hypernovae associated with long duration GRBs, is under intense debate. In this context, SN2008D associated with XT080109 could represent a paradigmatic case, since it might exemplify a potential borderline event. The main aim is to infer geometric information of SN2008D through the evolution of its linear optical polarization. We also report the polarization evolution of SN2007uy, and discuss the properties of the host ISM towards the XT. The final goal is to compare the polarization properties, and hence the geometries of both SNe, which shone contemporaneously in NGC2770. This fortunate coincidence brought us the opportunity to observe both SNe simultaneously, and most importantly, with identical instrumental setups. The observations span 74.9 days, starting 3.6 days after the XT and are distributed in 11 visits. In addition we performed observations in the mm range in order to identify the dominant polarization. We report positive linear polarization detections at several epochs for SN2008D at a level of ~1% and at ~1.5% for SN2007uy. SN2007uy shows constant polarization, which could be described by the host interstellar polarization plus a constant eccentricity expansion on the sky plane. A statistical analysis of the distribution of the SN2008D Stokes parametres suggests that it could show an intrinsic variable polarization component. Assuming the SN2007uy polarization is constant, we find that the evolution of the intrinsic SN2008D polarization could be explained by an aspherical axisymmetric expansion with variable eccentricity. We come to the same result even if we make no assumption on SN2007uy, although at a lower significance level. We suggest that at least the projected, if not the intrinsic, geometries of both SNe could differ.