A Simple Model for Solar Isorotational Contours

TL;DR

This paper proposes a simple model linking isentropic and isorotational surfaces in the solar convective zone, explaining observed rotation contours through thermal wind balance and aligning well with helioseismology data.

Contribution

It introduces a model where isentropes and isorotation surfaces coincide, providing a new explanation for the solar rotation profile consistent with observations.

Findings

Isorotation contours match helioseismology data

Horizontal contours at poles, axial at equator, radial at midlatitudes

Model predicts alignment of isentropes and isorotation surfaces in the SCZ

Abstract

The solar convective zone, or SCZ, is nearly adiabatic and marginally convectively unstable. But the SCZ is also in a state of differential rotation, and its dynamical stability properties are those of a weakly magnetized gas. This renders it far more prone to rapidly growing rotational baroclinic instabilities than a hydrodynamical system would be. These instabilities should be treated on the same footing as convective instabilites. If isentropic and isorotational surfaces coincide in the SCZ, the gas is marginally (un)stable to {\em both} convective and rotational disturbances. This is a plausible resolution for the instabilities associated with these more general rotating convective systems. This motivates an analysis of the thermal wind equation in which isentropes and isorotational surfaces are identical. The characteristics of this partial differential equation correspond to isorotation contours, and their form may be deduced even without precise knowledge of how the entropy and rotation are functionally related. Although the exact solution of the global SCZ problem in principle requires this knowledge, even the simplest models produce striking results in broad agreement with helioseismology data. This includes horizontal (i.e. quasi-spherical) isorotational contours at the poles, axial contours at the equator, and approximately radial contours at midlatitudes. The theory does not apply directly to the tachocline, where a simple thermal wind balance is not expected to be valid. The work presented here is subject to tests of self-consistency, among them the prediction that there should be good agreement between isentropes and isorotational contours in sufficiently well-resolved large scale numerical MHD simulations.