The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets: XIV. Gl 176b, a super-Earth rather than a Neptune, and at a different period

TL;DR

This study refines the detection of a super-Earth around Gl 176, contradicting earlier Neptune-mass claims, by using high-precision HARPS measurements that reveal a lower mass planet at a different orbital period.

Contribution

It provides the first clear detection of a super-Earth orbiting an M dwarf using HARPS, and refutes previous Neptune-mass planet claims based on less precise data.

Findings

No evidence for the previously claimed Neptune-mass planet.

Detection of an 8.4 Mearth super-Earth at 8.78-day period.

Host star shows magnetic activity with a 39-day rotation period.

Abstract

A 10.24 days Neptune-mass planet was recently announced to orbit the nearby M2 dwarf Gl 176, based on 28 radial velocities measured with the HRS spectrograph on the Hobby-Heberly Telescope (HET). We obtained 57 radial velocities of Gl 176 with the ESO 3.6m telescope and the HARPS spectrograph, which is known for its sub-m/s stability. The median photon-noise standard error of our measurements is 1.1 m/s, significantly lower than the 4.7 m/s of the HET velocities, and the 4 years period over which they were obtained has much overlap with the epochs of the HET measurements. The HARPS measurements show no evidence for a signal at the period of the putative HET planet, suggesting that its detection was spurious. We do find, on the other hand, strong evidence for a lower mass 8.4 Mearth planet, in a quasi-circular orbit and at the different period of 8.78 days. The host star has moderate magnetic activity and rotates on a 39-days period, which we confirm through modulation of both contemporaneous photometry and chromospheric indices. We detect that period as well in the radial velocities, but it is well removed from the orbital period and no cause for confusion. This new detection of a super-Earth (2 Mearth < M sin(i) < 10 Mearth) around an M dwarf adds to the growing evidence that such planets are common around very low mass stars: a third of the 20 known planets with M sin(i) < 0.1 Mjup and 3 of the 7 known planets with M sin(i) < 10 Mearth orbit an M dwarf, in contrast to just 4 of the ~300 known Jupiter-mass planets.