Crash-testing the CAULDRON code for joint lensing and dynamics analysis of early-type galaxies

TL;DR

This study tests the CAULDRON code's ability to analyze early-type galaxies with complex structures, demonstrating it can reliably recover key properties despite violations of its assumptions.

Contribution

The paper evaluates CAULDRON's robustness on a non-ideal, rotating N-body galaxy, showing it still accurately recovers global properties even when assumptions are violated.

Findings

Total density slope recovered within 10%

Dark matter fraction estimated within 10%

Angular momentum and anisotropy parameters reliably inferred

Abstract

We apply the joint lensing and dynamics code for the analysis of early-type galaxies, CAULDRON, to a rotating N-body stellar system with dark matter halo which significantly violates the two major assumptions of the method, i.e. axial symmetry supported by a two-integral distribution function. The goal is to study how CAULDRON performs in an extreme case, and to determine which galaxy properties can still be robustly recovered. Three data sets, corresponding to orthogonal lines of sight, are generated from the N-body system and analysed with the identical procedure followed in the study of real lens galaxies, adopting an axisymmetric power-law total density distribution. We find that several global properties of the N-body system are recovered with remarkable accuracy, despite the fact that the adopted power-law model is too simple to account for the lack of symmetry of the true density distribution. In particular, the logarithmic slope of the total density distribution is robustly recovered to within less than 10 per cent (with the exception of the ill-constrained very inner regions), the inferred angle-averaged radial profile of the total mass closely follows the true distribution, and the dark matter fraction of the system (inside the effective radius) is correctly determined within ~ 10 per cent of the total mass. Unless the line of sight direction is almost parallel to the total angular momentum vector of the system, reliably recovered quantities also include the angular momentum, the V/sigma ratio, and the anisotropy parameter delta. We conclude that the CAULDRON code can be safely and effectively applied to real early-type lens galaxies, providing reliable information also for systems that depart significantly from the method's assumptions.