Stellar Evolution and Variability in the Pre-ZAHB Phase

TL;DR

This paper explores the potential of pre-zero-age horizontal branch stars to be identified as variable stars, particularly RR Lyrae, by modeling their evolution and pulsation properties in the globular cluster M3.

Contribution

It provides the first theoretical analysis linking high period change rate RR Lyrae stars to pre-ZAHB evolutionary phase using detailed stellar evolution and pulsation modeling.

Findings

Approximately 1 pre-ZAHB star per 60 HB stars in M3.

22% of pre-ZAHB stars within the instability strip show RR Lyrae-like pulsations.

76% of predicted pre-ZAHB pulsators have negative P-dot values.

Abstract

One of the most dramatic events in the life of a low-mass star is the He flash, which takes place at the tip of the RGB and is followed by a series of secondary flashes before the star settles on the zero-age HB (ZAHB). Yet, no stars have ever been positively identified in this key phase in the life of a low-mass star (hereafter the "pre-ZAHB" phase). We investigate the possibility that some pre-ZAHB stars may cross the instability strip (IS), thus becoming variable. In particular, it has been suggested that some RR Lyrae stars (RRL) with high period change rates (P-dot) may in fact be pre-ZAHB stars. We present the first theoretical effort devoted to interpreting some of the high-P-dot stars as pre-ZAHB pulsators. We constructed a grid of evolutionary tracks using the Garching Stellar Evolution Code for a chemical composition appropriate to the case of the globular cluster M3, where a number of stars with high P-dot values are found. We follow each star's pre-ZAHB evolution in detail, compute periods and P-dot values for the stars lying inside the IS, and produce pre-ZAHB Monte Carlo simulations for the case of M3. Our results indicate that one should expect of order 1 pre-ZAHB star for every 60 or so bona-fide HB stars in M3. Among the pre-ZAHB stars, ~22% are expected to fall within the IS boundaries, presenting RRL-like pulsations. On average, the pre-ZAHB pulsators are expected to have longer periods than the bona-fide HB pulsators, and 76% of them are predicted to show negative P-dot values. The most likely P-dot value for the pre-ZAHB variables is ~-0.3 d/Myr, but more extreme P-dot values are also possible: 38% of the variables are predicted to have P-dot < -0.8 d/Myr. It appears likely, therefore, that some RRL stars in M3 with high (absolute) P-dot values are pre-ZAHB pulsators in disguise. (abridged)