Altruism in Atomic Congestion Games

TL;DR

This paper explores how introducing altruistic agents into atomic congestion games affects equilibrium existence, stability, and convergence, providing algorithms and complexity results for various game types and incentive mechanisms.

Contribution

It models altruism as a trade-off in congestion games, analyzes equilibrium properties, and develops algorithms and hardness results for incentivizing altruistic behavior.

Findings

Nash equilibria exist for symmetric singleton games with convex delays

Polynomial-time algorithm to decide equilibrium existence for symmetric singleton games with arbitrary delays

NP-hardness of equilibrium existence in general congestion games with linear delays

Abstract

This paper studies the effects of introducing altruistic agents into atomic congestion games. Altruistic behavior is modeled by a trade-off between selfish and social objectives. In particular, we assume agents optimize a linear combination of personal delay of a strategy and the resulting increase in social cost. Our model can be embedded in the framework of congestion games with player-specific latency functions. Stable states are the Nash equilibria of these games, and we examine their existence and the convergence of sequential best-response dynamics. Previous work shows that for symmetric singleton games with convex delays Nash equilibria are guaranteed to exist. For concave delay functions we observe that there are games without Nash equilibria and provide a polynomial time algorithm to decide existence for symmetric singleton games with arbitrary delay functions. Our algorithm can be extended to compute best and worst Nash equilibria if they exist. For more general congestion games existence becomes NP-hard to decide, even for symmetric network games with quadratic delay functions. Perhaps surprisingly, if all delay functions are linear, then there is always a Nash equilibrium in any congestion game with altruists and any better-response dynamics converges. In addition to these results for uncoordinated dynamics, we consider a scenario in which a central altruistic institution can motivate agents to act altruistically. We provide constructive and hardness results for finding the minimum number of altruists to stabilize an optimal congestion profile and more general mechanisms to incentivize agents to adopt favorable behavior.