Critical Solutions of Three Vortex Motion in the Parabolic Case

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the global dynamics of three vortex motion in the parabolic case, demonstrating that vortex coalescence is an almost impossible event, thus extending previous local stability results.

Contribution

It offers a complete description of the vortex configurations near the critical curve C, filling gaps in the understanding of vortex coalescence in the parabolic case.

Findings

Vortex coalescence is almost never observed.

Stable and unstable families of vortex configurations are characterized.

Global dynamics near the critical curve C are fully described.

Abstract

Grobli (1877) laid the foundation for the analysis of the motion of three point vortices in a plane by deriving governing equations for triangular configurations of the vortices. Synge (1949) took this formulation one step further to that of a similar triangle of unit perimeter, via trilinear coordinates. The final reduced problem is governed by an integrable two-dimensional system of differential equations with solutions represented as planar trajectories. Another key to Synge's analysis was his classification of the problem into three distinct cases: elliptic, hyperbolic and parabolic corresponding, respectively, to the sum of products of pairs of vortex strengths being positive, negative or zero. The reduction of the vortex configuration, a curve in space to a planar curve is one-to-one, except along a critical planar curve C in the parabolic case. Each point on C represents a triangle of unit perimeter corresponding to a family of similar vortex configurations, expanding or contracting. The latter would lead to coelescence of the three vortices. Tavantzis and Ting (1988) filled most of the gaps left by Synge regarding the dynamics of the problem, and showed in particular that points on C corresponding to similar expanding families of vortex configurations are stable while those corresponding to similar contracting families are unstable. Their investigations yielded an exhaustive description of the motion and stability of three vortices in a plane except for the global behavior of the vortex configurations in a narrow strip containing C. The main contribution of this paper is a complete description of the global dynamics in such a strip, which emphaticallly demonstrates that three distinct vortices almost never coalesce.