Does avian magnetoreception rely on both magnetite and maghemite?
Michael Winklhofer, Joseph L. Kirschvink

TL;DR
This paper critically examines the hypothesis that avian magnetoreception involves both magnetite and maghemite, arguing that recent claims lack supporting data and contradict existing crystallographic and magnetic evidence.
Contribution
The authors challenge recent claims about magnetite and maghemite's roles in bird magnetoreception, highlighting inconsistencies with established crystallographic and magnetic data.
Findings
Recent claims are not supported by data.
Contradictions with previous crystallographic studies.
Magnetite and maghemite's roles are questioned.
Abstract
Recently, a putative magnetoreceptor in the upper-beak skin of homing pigeons was chemically characterized using X-ray flourescence and absorbtion studies [Fleissner et al., 2007. A novel concept of Fe-mineral based magnetoreception: histological and physiochemical data from the upper beak of homing pigeons. Naturwissenschaften 94 (8), 631-642]. In this short communication we point out that the novel concept propagated is based on conclusions that are not supported by data and, in fact, stand in contradiction to previously published crystallographic and magnetic data.
Peer Reviews
No public reviews on file for this paper yet. If you reviewed it on a platform where reviews are public (OpenReview, ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML), you can paste yours below so the community can read it here.
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsIron Metabolism and Disorders
The reference list from the paper itself. Each links out to its DOI / PubMed record.
- 1Fleissner et al. (2007 a) G. Fleissner, B. Stahl, P. Thalau, G. Falkenberg, and G. Fleissner, Naturwissenschaften 94 , 631 (2007 a).
- 2O’Day et al. (2004) P. O’Day, N. Rivera, R. Root, and S. A. Carroll, Am. Mineral. 89 , 572 (2004).
- 3Kirschvink and Lowenstam (1979) J. L. Kirschvink and H. A. Lowenstam, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 4 , 193 (1979).
- 4Fleissner et al. (2003) G. Fleissner, E. Holtkamp-Rötzler, M. Hanzlik, M. Winklhofer, G. Fleissner, N. Petersen, and W. Wiltschko, J. Comp. Neurol. 458 , 350 (2003).
- 5Hsu and Li (1994) C.-Y. Hsu and C.-W. Li, Science 265 , 95 (1994).
- 6Nichol and Locke (1995) H. Nichol and M. Locke, Science 269 , 1888 (1995).
- 7Kirschvink and Walker (1995) J. L. Kirschvink and M. M. Walker, Science 269 , 1889 (1995).
- 8Nesson (1995) M. H. Nesson, Science 269 , 1889 (1995).
