A Modified Y-M Action with Three Families of Fermionic Solitons and Perturbative Confinement
C. N. Ragiadakos

TL;DR
This paper introduces a modified SU(N) Yang-Mills model based on complex spacetime structures, revealing fermionic solitons with electron-like properties and a linear confining potential, suggesting a geometric unification approach.
Contribution
It presents a novel modified Yang-Mills action dependent on complex structures, classifies fermionic solitons, and demonstrates perturbative confinement without supersymmetry.
Findings
Fermionic solitons with electron-like properties are identified.
The model produces a linear static potential, indicating confinement.
Fermionic and bosonic modes are distinguished by periodicity conditions.
Abstract
The dynamics of a four dimensional generally covariant modified SU(N) Yang-Mills action, which depends on the complex structure of spacetime and not its metric, is studied. A general solution of the complex structure integrability conditions is found in the context of the G{2,2) Grassmannian manifold, which admits a global SL(4,C) symmetry group. A convenient definition of the physical energy and momentum permits the study of the vacuum and soliton sectors. The model has a set of conformally SU(2,2) invariant vacua and a set of Poincare invariant vacua. An algebraic integrability condition of the complex structure classifies the solitonic surfaces into three classes (families). The first class (spacetimes with two principal null directions) contains the Kerr-Newman complex structure, which has fermionic (electron-like) properties. That is the correct fermionic gyromagnetic ratio (g=2)…
Peer Reviews
No public reviews on file for this paper yet. If you reviewed it on a platform where reviews are public (OpenReview, ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML), you can paste yours below so the community can read it here.
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsNonlinear Waves and Solitons · Black Holes and Theoretical Physics · Numerical methods for differential equations
A MODIFIED Y-M ACTION WITH THREE FAMILIES OF FERMIONIC SOLITONS AND PERTURBATIVE CONFINEMENT
C. N. RAGIADAKOS
Pedagogical Institute
Mesogion 396, Agia Paraskevi, TK 15341, Greece
email: [email protected], [email protected]
ABSTRACT
The dynamics of a four dimensional generally covariant modified SU(N) Yang-Mills action, which depends on the complex structure of spacetime and not its metric, is studied. A general solution of the complex structure integrability conditions is found in the context of the Grassmannian manifold, which admits a global SL(4,C) symmetry group. A convenient definition of the physical energy and momentum permits the study of the vacuum and soliton sectors. The model has a set of conformally SU(2,2) invariant vacua and a set of Poincaré invariant vacua. An algebraic integrability condition of the complex structure classifies the solitonic surfaces into three classes (families). The first class (spacetimes with two principal null directions) contains the Kerr-Newman complex structure, which has fermionic (electron-like) properties. That is the correct fermionic gyromagnetic ratio (g=2) and it satisfies the correct electron equations of motion. The conjugate complex structure determines the antisoliton, which has the same mass and opposite charge. The fermionic solitons are differentiated from the complex structure bosonic modes by the periodicity condition on compactified spacetime. The non-periodicity of the found solitonic complex structures is proved. The modification of the Yang-Mills action has an essential consequence to the classical potential. It generates a linear static potential instead of the Coulomb-like potential of the ordinary Yang-Mills action. This linear potential implies that for every pure geometric soliton there are N solitonic gauge field excitations, which are perturbatively confined. The present model advocates a solitonic unification scheme without supersymmetry and/or superstrings.
Contents
1. INTRODUCTION
2. ACTION OF THE MODEL
2.1 Tetrad form of the action
2.2 Examples of complex structures
3. THE GRASSMANNIAN MANIFOLDS
3.1 Bounded and unbounded realizations of classical domain
3.2 Complex structures in context
3.3 Induced metrics on spacetimes
4. VACUA AND EXCITATION MODES
4.1 Physical energy-momentum
4.2 Conformal and Poincaré vacua
5. “LEPTONIC” SOLITONS
5.1 Three families of solitons
5.2 Massive complex structures of the 1st family
5.3 Solitonic features of the massive structures
5.4 Hopf invariants of complex structures
5.5 Massless complex structures of the 1st family
5.6 The 2nd and 3rd family solitons may be unstable
6. “HADRONIC” SOLITONS AND CONFINEMENT
1 INTRODUCTION
Standard Model appears to be amazingly successful in all its experimental testings. These successes can be found in many recent books in Quantum Field Theory. But it is generally believed that it is not a complete theory because it contains too many independent parameters. On the other hand many apparent phenomena have not yet been proven or successfully described. Quark confinement, the three generations of leptons, the corresponding three generations of quarks and the apparent correspondence between leptons and quarks are some characteristic physical phenomena, which have not yet been understood in the context of Quantum Field Theory. These characteristic features are proved to occur in the present slightly modified generally covariant Yang-Mills model, which has fermionic solitons without fermionic fields in its action.
General Relativity is actually a well established macroscopic theory. It is based on the Einstein equation
[TABLE]
where is the energy momentum tensor of the matter fields. is an external non-geometric quantity, which is formally imposed by hand. The classical mathematical problem of this theory is to compute the metric tensor , which satisfies the Einstein equation. The external character of has always been considered as a drawback of the theory and many efforts have been undertaken to derive it from geometry.
The two successful mainstreams (Quantum Field Theory and General Relativity) have been developed independently. Each branch has tried to incorporate the other one without apparent success. The straightforward “covariantization” of the Standard Model action with the Einstein gravitational term is not renormalizable. That is, it is not a self consistent Quantum Field Theory. These failures led researchers to look for non-conventional Lagrangian models. The mainstream of research turned first into Supergravity without success and after into Superstrings, without apparent experimental tests up to now. The first tests on supersymmetry are expected to be provided by the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) experiments. If supersymmetry is not found then research has to turn to more conventional models like the present solitonic one.
General Relativity researchers tried to generate particles in the context of Geometrodynamics, where matter is considered as a manifestation of geometry. The fundamental idea and expectation is to derive all particles from pure geometric quantities. The Einstein equation (1.1) is seen as the definition of the energy-momentum tensor of these particles. The Einstein-Infeld-Hoffman theory[3] of motion in General Relativity may be considered the origin of the geometrodynamic ideas. In this context the particle appears as a singularity of the Einstein tensor and the equation of motion is derived from the self-consistency identity and the definitions of center of mass and the momenta. This result came up as a surprise for many researchers, who were used to the linear character of the Maxwell equations, and the problem has been extensively studied[9]. Apparently the geometrodynamic point of view has also to postulate the (fundamental) equations, which the solitonic manifold must satisfy, and how the well known form of the Maxwell energy-momentum tensor is derived. In the Misner-Wheeler model[10] the fundamental equations are the Rainich conditions[27]. The metric configuration is the “particle” itself, and the electric charge is defined using an Einstein-Rosen wormhole[4] structure of space time. Despite its great philosophical appeal this program fails to describe many characteristic physical phenomena. It cannot explain the weak and the strong interactions, its solitonic particles have continuous mass and charge parameters, it is full of spinless solitons which do not appear in nature, etc, etc. One may think that the Rainich conditions are responsible for these unphysical consequences. But it has been proven that it is not the case. The Finkelstein-Misner topological analysis[6] showed that any set of (fundamental) equations applied to the metric tensor cannot imply soliton (particle, mass, etc.) discretization. It was this no-go result, that blocked any investigation for a new realistic geometrodynamic model and made this interesting idea to fade away.
Geometrodynamics has also failed to generate quantum phenomena but this effort had two extraordinary results which are purely microscopic. The first result is the derivation of the electron equations of motion[15],[2],[13] with the right terms without any effort of model building. The second one is the observation[1],[11] that the Kerr-Newman spacetime has the electron gyromagnetic ratio . These two results strongly suggested the identification of the electron with the charged Kerr manifold but the appropriate Quantum Field Theoretic model was missing. The value of the present model is that it may play this role or it may show the way how to find such a theory, which could incorporate these extraordinary results into Quantum Field Theory. This unification procedure does not need supersymmetry, because the fermionic particles appear as solitons of the model. That is the proposed particle unification scheme is of solitonic and not supersymmetric origin. In a solitonic unification schemes Standard Model is simply an effective action like the phonon actions in solids and fluids[28]. If the next few years the LHC experiments do not find supersymmetric particles, we have to turn to solitonic unification schemes as suggested by the present model.
The model started[21] as a simple exercise to find a four dimensional generally covariant action which would depend on the complex structure of the spacetime and not on its metric. Recall that this property characterizes the two dimensional string action. The purpose of this search was to find a renormalizable generally covariant action without higher order derivatives. Metric independence assures renormalizability[26], because the regularization procedure cannot generate non-renormalizable geometric terms. Only topological anomalies may appear. Calculations[26] of the first order one-loop diagrams in a convenient gauge condition show that they are finite. The action[22] of the model is reviewed in section 2, where the properties of the Lorentzian complex structure[7] are reviewed[8]. The new result of this section is the general solution of the complex structure integrability conditions using structure coordinates. A large part of the present paper is devoted to review the mathematical background because it is no used in current particle physics.
In section 3, the formalism of the Grassmannian manifolds and the classical domains is applied to reveal the invariance of the complex structures under the four dimensional global which is analogous to the symmetry of the string action. This mathematical background is necessary for the reader to understand the vacua and soliton sectors of the model and how global breaks down to the conformal and the physical Poincaré symmetries, which are studied in section 4. The natural emergence of the Poincaré group is the most interesting result of the present model. It permits to find massive and massless stationary axisymmetric solitons and to classify the complex structures using the Hopf invariant. This rich physical content of the model is revealed in section 4. The complex structures with solitonic properties are classified[25] into three classes relative to the number of sheets of the complex structure. The first two-valued class is extensively studied. They are solitons because their complex structures cannot be compactified. The antisolitons are simply the complex conjugate complex structures of the solitons. Solitons and antisolitons have the same mass but opposite charges. The general forms of these massive and massless stationary axisymmetric solitons are computed. An analogous calculation indicates that the other two classes of solitons (with three and four sheets) do not contain stable massive solitons.
The model contains only a Yang-Mills field and the ordinary (null) tetrad which determines the Lorentzian complex structure. The symmetries of the model do not permit the existence of fermionic fields. In section 5 we show that the modification of the Yang-Mills action, which makes it independent of the metric tensor, has a characteristic physical consequence. The static potential of a source is no longer but it is linear, which could confine the “colored” sources[25]. From the two dimensional solitonic models we know that the solitons may be excited by the field modes. Analogous excitations are expected in the present case too. That is, the solitonic complex structures of the model may be excited by the gauge field modes. Then these excited solitons are perturbatively confined because of the linear gauge field potential. Only “colorless” states may exist free, which is a characteristic property of the hadrons. Notice that this confinement mechanism implies a strict correspondence between “leptonic” pure geometric solitons with vanishing gauge field and the “hadronic” ones with non-vanishing gauge field.
2 ACTION OF THE MODEL
The ordinary (Euclidean) almost complex structure is a real tensor , normalized by the condition
[TABLE]
It defines an (integrable) complex structure, if it satisfies the Nijenhuis integrability condition
[TABLE]
Then the manifold over which exists, becomes a complex manifold.
A complex structure is compatible with the metric tensor of the manifold, if the two tensors satisfy the relation
[TABLE]
at any point of the manifold. If the signature of spacetime is Lorentzian, there is always a coordinate transformation such that the metric tensor takes the form of the Minkowski metric at a given point. Then we see that the real tensor defines a Lorentz transformation at the given point. However there is no real Lorentz transformation, which satisfies the normalization condition (2.1) of the complex structure. Notice that this incompatibility is a pure local property and it is not related to the global structure of spacetime.
Hence the Lorentzian signature of spacetime is not compatible with a real tensor (complex structure) . The notion of the Lorentzian complex structure has been generalized[7] to include complex tensors . I anticipate that the existence of antisolitons in the present model is based on this particular property of the Lorentzian complex structure. This (modified) complex structure has been extensively studied by Flaherty[8]. It can be shown that there is always a null tetrad such that the metric tensor and the complex structure tensor take the form
[TABLE]
The integrability condition of this complex structure implies the Frobenius integrability conditions of the pairs and . That is
[TABLE]
Frobenius theorem states that there are four complex functions , , such that
[TABLE]
These four functions are the structure coordinates of the (integrable) complex structure. Notice that in the present case of Lorentzian spacetimes the coordinates are not complex conjugate of , because is no longer a real tensor.
The reality conditions of the Newman-Penrose null tetrad imply
[TABLE]
These relations are directly proven after a substitution of (2.6). They are equivalent to the existence of two real functions , and a complex one , such that
[TABLE]
Notice that these relations provide an algebraic solution to the problem of complex structures on a spacetime. They are much easier handled than the PDEs (2.5). In the next section they will be transcribed in the Grassmannian manifold context providing a powerful mathematical machinery for the computation of complex structures.
The integrability conditions of the complex structure can be formulated in the spinor formalism. They imply that both spinors and of the dyad satisfy the same PDE
[TABLE]
where is the covariant derivative connected to the vierbein . This relation is equivalent to the existence of a complex vector field such that
[TABLE]
Using the relation[18]
[TABLE]
one can show that both and satisfy the algebraic integrability condition
[TABLE]
Namely, they are principal directions of the Weyl spinor . Therefore a curved spacetime may admit a limited number of complex structures, which are directly related to its principal null directions. If the Weyl curvature vanishes, there is no restriction on the proper spinor basis. In this case the manifold is conformally flat and the integrability conditions are completely solved via Kerr’s theorem[8].
2.1 Tetrad and structure coordinate forms of the action
The string action describes the dynamics of 2-dimensional surfaces in a multidimensional space. Its form
[TABLE]
does not essentially depend on the metric of the 2-dimensional surface. It depends on its structure coordinates , because in these coordinates it takes the metric independent form
[TABLE]
All the wonderful properties of the string model are essentially based on this characteristic feature of the string action.
The plausible question[21] and exercise is “what 4-dimensional action with first order derivatives depends on the complex structure but it does not depend on the metric of the spacetime?”. The additional expectation is that such an action may be formally renormalizable because the regularization procedure will not generate geometric counterterms. The term “formally” is used because the 4-dimensional action may have anomalies which could destroy renormalizability, as it happens in the string action. Recall that the string and superstring actions are self-consistent only in precise dimensions, where the cancellation of the anomaly occurs.
A four dimensional action which satisfies the above criterion was found. The null tetrad form of this action[22] of the present model is
[TABLE]
where is a gauge field and is an integrable null tetrad. The difference between the present action and the ordinary Yang-Mills action becomes more clear in the following form of the action.
[TABLE]
where is a metric derived from the null tetrad and is the tensor of the integrable complex structure.
Like the 2-dimensional string action, the metric independence of the present action appears when we transcribe it in its structure coordinates form
[TABLE]
This transcription is possible because the metric and the integrable null tetrad take simple forms in the structure coordinates system.
In the case of the string action we do not need additional conditions because any orientable 2-dimensional surface admits a complex structure. But in the case of 4-dimensional surfaces, the integrability of the complex structure has to be imposed through precise conditions. These integrability conditions may be imposed either on the tetrad (2.5) or on the structure coordinates (2.7), using the ordinary procedure of Lagrange multipliers. These different possibilities will provide the various forms of the action which are equivalent, at least in the classical level. Its different variations should be seen as different ways to write down the integration measure over the complex structures of the 4-dimensional Lorentzian manifolds. The additional action term with the integrability conditions on the null tetrad is
[TABLE]
This Lagrange multiplier makes the complete action self-consistent and the usual quantization techniques may be used[24].
The local symmetries of the action are a) the well known local gauge transformations, b) the reparametrization symmetry as it is the case in any generally covariant action and c) the following extended Weyl transformation of the tetrad
[TABLE]
where are real functions and is a complex one.
2.2 Examples of complex structures
In order to make a selfconsistent paper we will present here some examples of complex structures, which can also be found in the works of Flaherty. The configurations of these complex structures will be used in the next sections.
The spinorial form of the integrability condition of the complex structure is conformally invariant. It is invariant under a spinor multiplication with an arbitrary function, therefore we do not loose generality assuming the form . Then, in the Cartesian coordinates of a conformally flat spacetime the spinorial integrability conditions become the Kerr differential equations
[TABLE]
where the Penrose spinorial notation is used with
[TABLE]
Kerr’s theorem states that a general solution of these equations is any function , which satisfies a relation of the form
[TABLE]
where is an arbitrary function.
Notice that in a conformally flat spacetime, the two solutions and , which determine the spinor dyad and , completely decouple. A characteristic example of a Minkowski spacetime complex structure is given by the two solutions of the quadratic (Kerr) function
[TABLE]
where the ordinary Cartesian coordinates are used. This Kerr function is time independent and determines a static complex structure. The two solutions are
[TABLE]
The corresponding spinor basis (dyad) is
[TABLE]
The corresponding null tetrad is
[TABLE]
which is the “flatprint” null tetrad of the Kerr-Newman manifold. In the case of it becomes the trivial “spherical” complex structure.
In the case of conformally flat spacetimes the structure coordinates are two independent functions of and the structure coordinates are respectively two independent functions of . It is convenient to use the following structure coordinates
[TABLE]
Notice that this complex structure cannot be defined over the whole Minkowski spacetime, because it is singular when , which occurs at
[TABLE]
We will see below that these points do not belong to the Grassmannian manifold. Using the Lindquist coordinates
[TABLE]
the structure coordinates take the form
[TABLE]
The Minkowski spacetime null tetrad takes the form
[TABLE]
A simple way[23],[25] to find a curved space complex structure is the Kerr-Schild ansatz
[TABLE]
where the null tetrad determines an integrable flat complex structure. In the case of the static (2.31) complex structure, is integrable for
[TABLE]
where is an arbitrary function. Notice that for the Kerr-Newman space-time is found. A set of structure coordinates of the curved complex structure, which are smooth deformations of the Minkowski complex structure, are
[TABLE]
where the two new functions are
[TABLE]
In the present model these configurations are seen as solitons. The complex structure describes a fermionic soliton with charge and its complex conjugate describes an antisoliton with charge .
3 THE G2,2 GRASSMANNIAN MANIFOLD
The present work is heavily based on projective spaces and the classical domains, therefore a short review of the projective Grassmannian manifolds and the classical domain is needed. The projective space is the set of non vanishing 4-d complex vector with the equivalence relation if there exists a non vanishing complex number such that . Then the natural topology of induces a well defined topology in . The coordinates are called homogeneous coordinates and the three coordinates y^{I}=[\frac{Z^{1}}{Z^{0}}\ ,\ are called projective coordinates in the coordinate neighborhood. Every two elements and of determine a matrix such that
[TABLE]
where they are written in the chiral representation. Penrose[16] has observed that a general solution of the Kerr theorem, which determines the geodetic and shear free congruences, take the simple form , where is a homogeneous function. In the case of a first degree polynomial with we may define
[TABLE]
After a straightforward calculation we find that satisfy the differential equation
[TABLE]
Penrose points out that the inverse is also true. The space of the solutions of this differential equation is . He called this differential equation “twistor equation” and the projective space twistor space. One can easily show that if of satisfy the relations
[TABLE]
with
[TABLE]
the generally complex matrix becomes Hermitian and it transforms as the Cartesian coordinates of the Minkowski spacetime under the Poincaré subgroup of the projective transformations of . Penrose tried to extract physical meaning from these relations. I will not continue on twistor mode of thinking, because I want to avoid confusion of the present conventional quantum field theoretic model with the Penrose twistor program. But many times in the present work we will use the twistor formalism and its spinor notation, because it is computationally very effective.
In the case of a second degree polynomial with
[TABLE]
we define the spinor
[TABLE]
which satisfies the relation
[TABLE]
In the case of a fourth degree polynomial we find
[TABLE]
which also satisfies the twistor equation
[TABLE]
It is proved that a spinor , which satisfies the fourth degree homogeneous polynomial
[TABLE]
determines a geodetic and shear free congruence in Minkowski spacetime. Two roots of this polynomial define a complex structure. This relation is useful, because it will coincide with the algebraic integrability condition on the curved spacetime in the weak gravity approximation. That is, we expect the Weyl spinorial tensor to become proportional with in the weak gravity limit and in an appropriate (Cartesian) coordinate system.
Let us now turn to the definition of the Grassmannian projective manifold . Consider the set of the complex matrices of rank 2
[TABLE]
with the equivalence relation if there exists a regular matrix such that
[TABLE]
The coordinates
[TABLE]
completely determine the points of the set. The topology of the matrices implies a well defined topology in this projective manifold . The coordinates are called homogeneous coordinates and the coordinates