Discussion of: Statistical analysis of an archeological find--skeptical counting challenges to an archaeological find

TL;DR

This paper critically examines Feuerverger's statistical analysis of an archaeological find, highlighting potential challenges and limitations in the original methodology and interpretations.

Contribution

It provides a skeptical perspective on the statistical methods used in the original analysis, offering insights into possible improvements.

Findings

Identifies potential flaws in Feuerverger's statistical approach

Highlights the importance of rigorous skepticism in archaeological statistics

Suggests alternative methods for analyzing archaeological data

Abstract

Discussion of ``Statistical analysis of an archeological find'' by Andrey Feuerverger [arXiv:0804.0079]