New Implementation Framework for Saturation-Based Reasoning

TL;DR

This paper proposes new architectural principles for saturation-based reasoning systems, aiming to overcome current limitations in inference selection and search prioritization to potentially achieve significant performance improvements.

Contribution

It introduces a flexible inference selection mechanism and a method for intelligent search direction prioritization to enhance saturation-based theorem provers.

Findings

Proposed a high-precision inference selection mechanism.

Outlined a method for probing and prioritizing search directions.

Discussed implementation strategies for the new architectural principles.

Abstract

The saturation-based reasoning methods are among the most theoretically developed ones and are used by most of the state-of-the-art first-order logic reasoners. In the last decade there was a sharp increase in performance of such systems, which I attribute to the use of advanced calculi and the intensified research in implementation techniques. However, nowadays we are witnessing a slowdown in performance progress, which may be considered as a sign that the saturation-based technology is reaching its inherent limits. The position I am trying to put forward in this paper is that such scepticism is premature and a sharp improvement in performance may potentially be reached by adopting new architectural principles for saturation. The top-level algorithms and corresponding designs used in the state-of-the-art saturation-based theorem provers have (at least) two inherent drawbacks: the insufficient flexibility of the used inference selection mechanisms and the lack of means for intelligent prioritising of search directions. In this position paper I analyse these drawbacks and present two ideas on how they could be overcome. In particular, I propose a flexible low-cost high-precision mechanism for inference selection, intended to overcome problems associated with the currently used instances of clause selection-based procedures. I also outline a method for intelligent prioritising of search directions, based on probing the search space by exploring generalised search directions. I discuss some technical issues related to implementation of the proposed architectural principles and outline possible solutions.