On the absence of shear from perfect Einstein rings and the stability of geometry

TL;DR

This paper investigates the stability of the Universe's geometry by analyzing cosmic shear effects, especially through the shape of Einstein rings, revealing less shear than expected and questioning the robustness of large-scale curvature.

Contribution

It introduces a novel method of testing cosmic shear via Einstein ring shapes, challenging current understanding of inhomogeneous universe effects on geometry stability.

Findings

Most Einstein rings are nearly circular, indicating lower shear levels than predicted.

Cosmic shear effects are weaker than current models suggest.

Implications for the stability of the Universe's large-scale geometry.

Abstract

Concordance cosmology points to a Universe of zero mean curvature, due to the inflation mechanism which occurred soon after the Big Bang, while along a relatively small number of lower redshift light paths where lensing events are observed, space is positively curved. How do we know that global geometry and topology are robust rather than in a state of chaos? The phenomenon of cosmic shear provides an effective way of mapping curvature fluctuations, because it affects {\it any} light rays whether they intercept mass clumps or not. We discuss a range of astrophysical applications of the principal manifestation of shear - the distortion of images. It will be shown that the quickest way of testing the existence of shear in the near Universe is to look at the shape of Einstein rings. The fact that most of these rings are circular to a large extent means, statistically speaking, shear occurs at a much lower level than the expectation based upon our current understanding of the inhomogeneous Universe. While inflation may account for the mean geometry, it offers no means of stabilizing it against the fluctuations caused by non-linear matter clumping at low redshift. Either this clumping is actually much less severe, or the physical mechanism responsible for shaping the large scale curvature has been active not only during the very early epochs, but also at all subsequent times. Might it be the vital `interface' between expansion on Hubble distances and gravity on cluster scales and beneath?