Understanding the WMAP Cold Spot mystery

TL;DR

This paper investigates the WMAP Cold Spot, revealing it results from large-scale modulations in the CMB signal primarily caused by multipoles between 10 and 20, and that the remaining signal is statistically homogeneous and Gaussian.

Contribution

The study provides a detailed analysis linking the Cold Spot to specific multipole components and demonstrates that the overall CMB sky is statistically homogeneous after accounting for these modulations.

Findings

The Cold Spot is associated with a large group of extrema, not just one.

The shape of the Cold Spot is mainly formed by multipoles between 10 and 20.

After removing the modulation, the CMB signal appears Gaussian and homogeneous.

Abstract

The first and third year data releases from the WMAP provide evidence of an anomalous Cold Spot (CS) at galactic latitude b=-57deg and longitude l=209deg. We have examined the properties of the CS in some detail in order to assess its cosmological significance. We have performed a cluster analysis of the local extrema in the CMB signal to show that the CS is actually associated with a large group of extrema rather than just one. In the light of this we have re-examined the properties of the WMAP ILC and co-added "cleaned" WCM maps, which have previously been used for the analysis of the properties of the signal in the vicinity of the CS. These two maps have remarkably similar properties on equal latitude rings for |b|>30deg, as well as in the vicinity of the CS. We have also checked the idea that the CMB signal has a non-Gaussian tail, localized in the low multipole components of the signal. For each ring we apply a linear filter with characteristic scale R, dividing the CMB signal in two parts: the filtered part, with characteristic scale above that of the filter R, and the difference between the initial and filtered signal. Using the filter scale as a variable, we can maximize the skewness and kurtosis of the smoothed signal and minimize these statistics for the difference between initial and filtered signal. We have discovered that the shape of the CS is formed primarily by the components of the CMB signal represented by multipoles between 10<=L<=20, with a corresponding angular scale about 5-10 degs. This signal leads to modulation of the whole CMB sky, clearly seen at |b|>30deg in both the ILC and WCM maps, rather than a single localized feature. After subtraction of this modulation, the remaining part of the CMB signal appears to be consistent with statistical homogeneity and Gaussianity.