Comment on`` Angular dependence of Dicke-narrowed electromagnetically induced transparency resonances''

TL;DR

This paper critiques a previous experimental claim of Dicke narrowing in electromagnetically induced transparency, arguing that the reported results do not align with theoretical expectations.

Contribution

It provides a critical analysis showing the discrepancy between experimental results and theoretical predictions of Dicke narrowing in EIT.

Findings

Experimental results do not match theoretical predictions

Challenges previous claims of Dicke narrowing in EIT

Highlights need for reevaluation of experimental interpretations

Abstract

We demonstrate that the experimental results reported by M. Shuker, O. Firstenberg, R. Pugatch, A. Ben-Kish,1 A. Ron, and N. Davidson, Phys. Rev. A {\bf 76}, 023813 (2007) as Dicke narrowing of electromagnetically induced transparency, does not match with theory.