h/e-Periodicity in Superconducting Loops

TL;DR

This paper reveals that many unconventional superconductors exhibit an h/e flux periodicity in superconducting loops, challenging the traditional h/2e periodicity assumption and highlighting a magnetic-field driven condensate reconstruction.

Contribution

It demonstrates that the ground-state energies and supercurrents in various unconventional superconductors are generically h/e periodic, based on BCS theory and condensate reconstruction mechanisms.

Findings

Unconventional superconductors show h/e periodicity in flux response.

BCS theory predicts h/e periodicity for multiply connected paths.

Magnetic-field induced condensate reconstruction causes the periodicity.

Abstract

The magnetic flux periodicity of superconducting loops as well as flux quantization itself are a manifestation of macroscopic quantum phenomena with far reaching implications. They provide the key to the understanding of many fundamental properties of superconductors and are the basis for most bulk and device applications of these materials. In superconducting rings the electrical current has been known to periodically respond to a magnetic flux with a periodicity of $\bm{h/2e}$. Here, the ratio of Planck's constant and the elementary charge defines the magnetic flux quantum $\bm{h/e}$. The well-known $\bm{h/2e}$ periodicity is viewed to be a hallmark for electronic pairing in superconductors and is considered evidence for the existence of Cooper pairs. Here we show that in contrast to this long-term belief, rings of many superconductor bear an $\bm{h/e}$ periodicity. These superconductors include the high-$\bm{T_c}$ cuprates, Sr$_2$RuO$_4$, the heavy-fermion superconductors, as well as all other unconventional superconductors with nodes in the energy gap functions, and s-wave superconductors with small gaps or states in the gap. As we show, the 50-year-old Bardeen--Cooper--Schrieffer theory of superconductivity implies that for multiply connected paths of such superconductors the ground-state energies and consequently also the supercurrents are generically $\bm{h/e}$ periodic. The origin of this periodicity is a magnetic-field driven reconstruction of the condensate and a concomitant Doppler-shifted energy spectrum. The robust, flux induced reconstruction of the condensate will be an important aspect to understand the magnetic properties of mesoscopic unconventional superconductors.