Oral messages improve visual search

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that multimodal oral messages combining speech and visual cues significantly enhance the speed and accuracy of visual search tasks on crowded displays, especially under higher difficulty levels.

Contribution

It provides empirical evidence on the efficiency and usability of oral spatial messages in aiding visual search, addressing a gap in multimodal output message design and evaluation.

Findings

Multimodal messages improve search speed and accuracy.

Participants preferred multimodal over visual-only messages.

Effectiveness varies with scene structure and task difficulty.

Abstract

Input multimodality combining speech and hand gestures has motivated numerous usability studies. Contrastingly, issues relating to the design and ergonomic evaluation of multimodal output messages combining speech with visual modalities have not yet been addressed extensively. The experimental study presented here addresses one of these issues. Its aim is to assess the actual efficiency and usability of oral system messages including brief spatial information for helping users to locate objects on crowded displays rapidly. Target presentation mode, scene spatial structure and task difficulty were chosen as independent variables. Two conditions were defined: the visual target presentation mode (VP condition) and the multimodal target presentation mode (MP condition). Each participant carried out two blocks of visual search tasks (120 tasks per block, and one block per condition). Scene target presentation mode, scene structure and task difficulty were found to be significant factors. Multimodal target presentation proved to be more efficient than visual target presentation. In addition, participants expressed very positive judgments on multimodal target presentations which were preferred to visual presentations by a majority of participants. Besides, the contribution of spatial messages to visual search speed and accuracy was influenced by scene spatial structure and task difficulty: (i) messages improved search efficiency to a lesser extent for 2D array layouts than for some other symmetrical layouts, although the use of 2D arrays for displaying pictures is currently prevailing; (ii) message usefulness increased with task difficulty. Most of these results are statistically significant.