The high mass end of the Tully-Fisher relation

TL;DR

This study reveals a kink at the high-mass end of the Tully-Fisher relation, showing massive disk galaxies deviate from the established relation, impacting distance measurements and galaxy evolution studies.

Contribution

It demonstrates that using asymptotic rotation velocities and baryonic mass removes deviations, refining the Tully-Fisher relation for massive galaxies.

Findings

Massive galaxies lie systematically off the traditional Tully-Fisher relation.

Using asymptotic rotation velocity reduces the high-mass slope change.

Baryonic mass aligns the relation across all galaxy masses.

Abstract

We study the location of massive disk galaxies on the Tully-Fisher relation. Using a combination of K-band photometry and high-quality rotation curves, we show that in traditional formulations of the TF relation (using the width of the global HI profile or the maximum rotation velocity), galaxies with rotation velocities larger than 200 km/s lie systematically to the right of the relation defined by less massive systems, causing a characteristic `kink' in the relations. Massive, early-type disk galaxies in particular have a large offset, up to 1.5 magnitudes, from the main relation defined by less massive and later-type spirals. The presence of a change in slope at the high-mass end of the Tully-Fisher relation has important consequences for the use of the Tully-Fisher relation as a tool for estimating distances to galaxies or for probing galaxy evolution. In particular, the luminosity evolution of massive galaxies since z = 1 may have been significantly larger than estimated in several recent studies. We also show that many of the galaxies with the largest offsets have declining rotation curves and that the change in slope largely disappears when we use the asymptotic rotation velocity as kinematic parameter. The remaining deviations from linearity can be removed when we simultaneously use the total baryonic mass (stars + gas) instead of the optical or near-infrared luminosity. Our results strengthen the view that the Tully-Fisher relation fundamentally links the mass of dark matter haloes with the total baryonic mass embedded in them.