GRB Energetics in the Swift Era

TL;DR

This study analyzes the energetics of 76 Swift-detected gamma-ray bursts, revealing that X-ray light curve breaks suggest a wider energy distribution than previously thought, challenging the standard energy model.

Contribution

It provides the first comprehensive analysis of X-ray light curves for Swift GRBs, highlighting differences from optical observations and implications for jet break interpretations.

Findings

Most GRBs have high enough redshift/low fluence for late jet breaks

X-ray breaks are shallower and occur earlier than optical breaks

The energy distribution post-Swift is broader than pre-Swift estimates

Abstract

We examine the rest frame energetics of 76 gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) with known redshift that were detected by the Swift spacecraft and monitored by the satellite's X-ray Telescope (XRT). Using the bolometric fluence values estimated in Butler et al. 2007b and the last XRT observation for each event, we set a lower limit the their collimation corrected energy Eg and find that a 68% of our sample are at high enough redshift and/or low enough fluence to accommodate a jet break occurring beyond the last XRT observation and still be consistent with the pre-Swift Eg distribution for long GRBs. We find that relatively few of the X-ray light curves for the remaining events show evidence for late-time decay slopes that are consistent with that expected from post jet break emission. The breaks in the X-ray light curves that do exist tend to be shallower and occur earlier than the breaks previously observed in optical light curves, yielding a Eg distribution that is far lower than the pre-Swift distribution. If these early X-ray breaks are not due to jet effects, then a small but significant fraction of our sample have lower limits to their collimation corrected energy that place them well above the pre-Swift Eg distribution. Either scenario would necessitate a much wider post-Swift Eg distribution for long cosmological GRBs compared to the narrow standard energy deduced from pre-Swift observations. We note that almost all of the pre-Swift Eg estimates come from jet breaks detected in the optical whereas our sample is limited entirely to X-ray wavelengths, furthering the suggestion that the assumed achromaticity of jet breaks may not extend to high energies.