On the abundance discrepancy problem in HII regions

TL;DR

This study investigates the abundance discrepancy in HII regions, finding it to be relatively constant and not strongly correlated with most nebular parameters, supporting the temperature fluctuations explanation over chemical inhomogeneities.

Contribution

The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the abundance discrepancy factor in HII regions, highlighting its constancy and dependence on excitation energy, and contrasting it with planetary nebulae.

Findings

The ADF is roughly constant around 2 in HII regions.

No significant correlation between ADF and nebular parameters.

Te from OII recombination lines agrees with collisionally excited lines.

Abstract

The origin of the abundance discrepancy is one of the key problems in the physics of photoionized nebula. In this work, we analize and discuss data for a sample of Galactic and extragalactic HII regions where this abundance discrepancy has been determined. We find that the abundance discrepancy factor (ADF) is fairly constant and of the order of 2 in all the available sample of HII regions. This is a rather different behaviour than that observed in planetary nebulae, where the ADF shows a much wider range of values. We do not find correlations between the ADF and the O/H, O++/H+ ratios, the ionization degree, Te(High), Te(Low)/ Te(High), FWHM, and the effective temperature of the main ionizing stars within the observational uncertainties. These results indicate that whatever mechanism is producing the abundance discrepancy in HII regions it does not substantially depend on those nebular parameters. On the contrary, the ADF seems to be slightly dependent on the excitation energy, a fact that is consistent with the predictions of the classical temperature fluctuations paradigm. Finally, we obtain that Te values obtained from OII recombination lines in HII regions are in agreement with those obtained from collisionally excited line ratios, a behaviour that is again different from that observed in planetary nebulae. These similar temperature determinations are in contradiction with the predictions of the model based on the presence of chemically inhomogeneous clumps but are consistent with the temperature fluctuations paradigm. We conclude that all the indications suggest that the physical mechanism responsible of the abundance discrepancy in HII regions and planetary nebulae are different.