Can Strong Gravitational Lensing Constrain Dark Energy?

TL;DR

This paper examines whether strong gravitational lensing can effectively constrain dark energy properties by analyzing the distance ratios and Einstein radius, concluding that current methods are limited but future improvements could help.

Contribution

It investigates the potential of using Einstein radius measurements in strong lensing to distinguish dark energy models, highlighting current limitations and future prospects.

Findings

Distance ratio differences are within velocity dispersion errors for most models.

Single lensing measurements may not effectively constrain dark energy.

Future mass profile understanding could improve constraints.

Abstract

We discuss the ratio of the angular diameter distances from the source to the lens, $D_{ds}$, and to the observer at present, $D_{s}$, for various dark energy models. It is well known that the difference of $D_s$s between the models is apparent and this quantity is used for the analysis of Type Ia supernovae. However we investigate the difference between the ratio of the angular diameter distances for a cosmological constant, $(D_{ds}/D_{s})^{\Lambda}$ and that for other dark energy models, $(D_{ds}/D_{s})^{\rm{other}}$ in this paper. It has been known that there is lens model degeneracy in using strong gravitational lensing. Thus, we investigate the model independent observable quantity, Einstein radius ($\theta_E$), which is proportional to both $D_{ds}/D_s$ and velocity dispersion squared, $\sigma_v^2$. $D_{ds}/D_s$ values depend on the parameters of each dark energy model individually. However, $(D_{ds}/D_s)^{\Lambda} - (D_{ds}/D_{s})^{\rm{other}}$ for the various dark energy models, is well within the error of $\sigma_v$ for most of the parameter spaces of the dark energy models. Thus, a single strong gravitational lensing by use of the Einstein radius may not be a proper method to investigate the property of dark energy. However, better understanding to the mass profile of clusters in the future or other methods related to arc statistics rather than the distances may be used for constraints on dark energy.