Dynamics and thermalization of the nuclear spin bath in the single-molecule magnet Mn12-ac: test for the theory of spin tunneling

TL;DR

This study investigates the nuclear spin bath dynamics in Mn12-ac single-molecule magnets at very low temperatures, revealing quantum tunneling effects and thermalization behaviors through NMR experiments, and compares findings with existing spin tunneling theories.

Contribution

It provides detailed experimental insights into nuclear spin relaxation and thermalization in Mn12-ac, testing and challenging current theories of macroscopic spin tunneling in the presence of a spin bath.

Findings

Nuclear relaxation becomes temperature-independent below 0.8 K.

Isotopic substitution slows nuclear relaxation, indicating tunneling dependence.

Nuclear spins remain in thermal equilibrium with phonons even at lowest temperatures.

Abstract

The description of the tunneling of a macroscopic variable in the presence of a bath of localized spins is a subject of great fundamental and practical interest, and is relevant for many solid-state qubit designs. Instead of focusing on the the "central spin" (as is most often done), here we present a detailed study of the dynamics of the nuclear spin bath in the Mn12-ac single-molecule magnet, probed by NMR experiments down to very low temperatures (T = 20 mK). We find that the longitudinal relaxation rate of the 55Mn nuclei in Mn12-ac becomes roughly T-independent below T = 0.8 K, and can be strongly suppressed with a longitudinal magnetic field. This is consistent with the nuclear relaxation being caused by quantum tunneling of the molecular spin, and we attribute the tunneling fluctuations to the minority of fast-relaxing molecules present in the sample. The transverse nuclear relaxation is also T-independent for T < 0.8 K, and can be explained qualitatively and quantitatively by the dipolar coupling between like nuclei in neighboring molecules. We also show that the isotopic substitution of 1H by 2H leads to a slower nuclear longitudinal relaxation, consistent with the decreased tunneling probability of the molecular spin. Finally, we demonstrate that, even at the lowest temperatures, the nuclear spins remain in thermal equilibrium with the lattice phonons, and we investigate the timescale for their thermal equilibration. After a review of the theory of macroscopic spin tunneling in the presence of a spin bath, we argue that most of our experimental results are consistent with that theory, but the thermalization of the nuclear spins is not.