Comment on "Influence of protons on the capture of electrons by 7Be in the Sun"

TL;DR

This paper critiques a previous study on how protons influence electron capture by 7Be in the Sun, highlighting conceptual flaws and questionable assumptions that undermine its conclusions.

Contribution

It provides a critical analysis pointing out conceptual and approximation issues in the prior work, questioning its validity.

Findings

Identifies conceptual difficulties in the original study

Highlights unjustified approximations affecting conclusions

Questions the reliability of previous results

Abstract

This paper suffers from conceptual difficulties and unjustified approximations that render its conclusions dubious.