A Systematic Study of Departures from Chemical Equilibrium in the Atmospheres of Substellar Mass Objects

TL;DR

This study systematically examines how departures from chemical equilibrium affect the spectra of substellar atmospheres, revealing modest but significant impacts on fluxes, especially in the M band, and improving spectral fits for T dwarfs.

Contribution

It introduces a comprehensive grid of non-equilibrium models for substellar atmospheres, incorporating various temperatures, gravities, and chemical reaction prescriptions, to better understand spectral features.

Findings

Non-equilibrium CO overabundance suppresses M band flux by up to 40%.

Underabundance of ammonia causes flux enhancements up to 20%.

Effects are more pronounced at lower gravity and higher eddy diffusion.

Abstract

We present a systematic study of the spectral consequences of departures from chemical equilibrium in the atmospheres of L and T dwarfs, and for even cooler dwarfs. The temperature/pressure profiles of the non-equilibrium models are fully consistent with the non-equilibrium chemistry. Our grid of non-equilibrium models includes spectra for effective temperatures from 200 K to 1800 K, three surface gravities, four possible values of the coefficient of eddy diffusion in the radiative zone, and three different CO/CH$_4$ chemical reaction prescriptions. We find that the non-equilibrium overabundance of CO translates into flux suppressions in the M ($\sim4-$5 $\mu$m) band of at most $\sim$40% between effective temperatures of 600 and 1800 K. The effect is largest around $T_{\rm eff} \approx 1100$ K. The underabundance of ammonia due to non-equilibrium chemistry translates into flux enhancements of no more than $\sim$20% for the $T_{\rm eff}$ range from 300 to 1800 K, with the largest effects at the lowest values of $T_{\rm eff}$. The magnitude of the departure from chemical equilibrium increases with decreasing gravity, with increasing eddy diffusion coefficient, and with decreasing speed of the CO/CH$_4$ reaction. Though these effects are modest, they lead to better fits with the measured T dwarf spectra. Furthermore, the suppression in the M band due to non-equilibrium enhancements in the CO abundance disappears below $\sim$500 K, and is only partial above $\sim$500 K, preserving the M band flux as a useful diagnostic of cool atmospheres and maintaining its importance for searches for brown dwarfs cooler than T dwarfs.